What the data shows
Four findings stand out once each car is compared only with identical cars at similar mileage:
- Priced in line sold fastest. Cars within 3% of the market had been on sale a median of 46 days, and 36% had been listed 30 days or less, the best of any group.
- Overpricing costs time. Cars more than 10% above the market had been on sale 72 days, and 56% had been listed for over 60 days. Only 55% had been reduced, so many dealers were holding their price.
- A small premium is not fatal. Cars 3% to 10% above the market had been on sale 51 days, close to cars priced in line. Lower mileage within the band, a better spec, colour or history can carry a modest premium.
- A low price is often a late price. Cars more than 10% below the market had been on sale 65 days and 77% had already been reduced. Most did not start cheap: they were cut after sitting.
Why the cheapest cars are not the quickest sellers
These are cars still for sale, so days on sale counts how long each one had been listed so far. A car that was priced at the market, sat for two months and was then reduced shows up as both cheap and old. That is why the groups below the market have the most price cuts and some of the longest days on sale.
The practical reading is about timing: the cars that moved fastest were the ones priced close to the market from the start, not the ones that were cut later. Pricing right on day one avoids both the slow sale and the reduction.
How to use this when you price a car
Simple rules that follow from the figures:
- Price within a few per cent of identical cars with similar mileage when the car first goes on sale.
- Only ask more when the buyer can see why: lower mileage, a better spec or colour, full history, or fresh tyres and service.
- Look at the price again after about two weeks, when an advert has had most of its views.
- Compare again once a car passes the typical days to sell for its model, rather than waiting for it to go stale.
- Check sold prices as well as asking prices, because asking prices on cars that are sitting overstate the market.
How to benchmark your prices against local competitors
Benchmarking means putting your car next to the identical cars other dealers are selling, with similar mileage, and seeing where your price sits. A live-market pricing tool does this from the registration, so you compare like with like instead of scrolling adverts.
On DealerPricing, one search on the registration shows:
- Every comparable car for sale at UK dealers, with price, mileage, days listed and distance
- Filters for mileage, year, gearbox, doors and distance, so you can narrow it to dealers near you
- Sold prices for identical cars from the last 90 days
- The DP Retail value and trade values for its mileage
- Days to sell, active supply and a market rating out of 10
- On Pro plans, My Stock lists the cars on your own website with price and days listed, ready to search one by one
How we worked this out
The adverts come from searches dealers ran on DealerPricing between 24 August to 22 November 2026, from 38 customer accounts. Our own staff, demo and test accounts are left out. Each search compares one car type, and an advert is only counted when there were at least six identical cars for sale and its mileage was within 25% of their median, so a price gap is not just a mileage gap. Each advert is counted once.
Limits worth knowing: the car types are the ones dealers chose to price, not a random sample of every car in the UK; the median advert was priced at £8,795, so the figures lean towards mainstream used stock; and the figures describe what we saw, not a promise about any one car. We publish groups only, never a registration, a dealer or an advert.
What it costs to check your own price position
DealerPricing plans are Basic 100 £70 a month for 100 searches, Pro 100 £99 for 100, Pro 200 £195 for 200. Searching the same registration again in the same billing month is free, so checking a car at listing and again at two weeks uses one search.
The first month is half price, there is no contract and no VAT is added.
